INDIANAPOLIS — Gray Zabel hesitated. The North Dakota State sort out did not know if he ought to reply the query posed by a reporter. The 2-time FCS nationwide champion performed 5 seasons for the Bison, and was one in all seven FCS gamers invited to the NFL mix this yr, the smallest variety of small faculty prospects, outlined as gamers who most just lately performed beneath the Division I FBS stage, in a decade. Zabel stated he had a couple of provides from greater packages to enter the switch portal.
How a lot cash did you permit on the desk by not getting into the switch portal for a Energy 4 FBS program final yr?
“That is a tricky reply,” Zabel stated, and paused to consider his phrases. “Six figures.”
“It isn’t simply me. There’s different very proficient gamers which might be getting tampered with each single yr, that our guys are being [enticed] to switch elsewhere. … It is powerful for lots of those guys to show down that kind of cash. However in the long term, you simply obtained to fall again to what you imagine in.”
Zabel stated he believed in Bison soccer, which he describes as a player-driven and process-driven program. He performed for a similar offensive line coach, Dan Larson, for the previous 4 years, a coach who has a report of growing gamers for the NFL. The Zabels have a household farm in South Dakota, and Gray did not have a lot NIL cash from NDSU, however he used what he needed to lease 245 acres of farmland in South Dakota. The Bison misplaced within the semifinals of the 2023 postseason, and he did not wish to finish his time in Fargo, North Dakota, that means.
“It is an vacancy that you just wish to fill instantly,” Zabel stated. He needed to be a nationwide champion once more, and he did that. Since then, he has been climbing draft boards due to a robust Senior Bowl week and flexibility to play guard and heart. He could possibly be a first-round decide, and lots of groups are asking him questions on why he did not transfer up.
“The greenback vary was in a spot the place you needed to contemplate it, and also you needed to actually give it some thought,” he stated. “It was a tough resolution, however on the finish of the day, it was an excellent simple resolution to determine to remain at North Dakota State and play my ultimate yr there due to the tradition, the relationships you make, the locker room that you just established and performed with the previous 4 years. You do not wish to depart these guys or depart that program, you wish to stick the place you began, keep residence, and in the long run, win the final recreation of the season.”
Zabel is a rarity in faculty now. NIL cash and the one-time switch rule, which went into impact for the 2021 faculty soccer season, allowed faculty athletes to switch as soon as and never sit out the season (the rule expanded in 2024 to permit limitless transfers with no penalties so long as gamers met educational necessities). That led to a gradual decline in small faculty gamers making the mix. They’re all transferring up earlier than they go professional.
“The Khalil Macks of the world [played four years at Buffalo of the MAC before going No. 5 in the 2014 draft] can be relics of the NFL drafts previous,” an analytics staffer for an NFL crew stated. “With the cash you get within the portal now — undecided we’ll ever see one other high 10 select of an FCS or decrease program once more.”
From 2016 to 2021, earlier than the switch rule, a median of 20.5 small schoolers had been invited to the mix. Since 2022, that common has dropped to 14.5, the bottom it has been prior to now 10 years.
Zero D-II or D-III prospects have been invited to the previous two combines. From 2015 to 2021, a median of three.5 sub-FCS gamers had been invited, with a excessive of seven D-II and D-III gamers invited in 2017.
If the small faculty prospect is on the verge of extinction, what does it imply for NFL groups?
ACCORDING TO AN NFL membership that shared its information with ESPN, two of 336 gamers (0.6%) within the 2018 scouting mix transferred to a better stage of faculty soccer (NAIA to D-II, FCS to FBS, for instance) from a non-FBS program. This yr, 28 of the 330 gamers (8.5%) invited to the scouting mix have transferred up at the least as soon as from a non-FBS program — 14 instances the variety of gamers who transferred up seven years in the past. A complete of 126 of this yr’s 330 (38.2%) transferred from any stage of faculty soccer at the least as soon as, with nearly all of these gamers transferring to a faculty on the identical stage. Solely 18 of 336 (5.4%) on the 2018 mix transferred at any level from any stage.
Two of the most important names on this draft class — Miami quarterback Cam Ward and Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders — are a part of the 2025 switch group. Ward went from FCS program Incarnate Phrase to FBS program Washington State, which was then a Energy 5 faculty, after which final yr, because the Pac-12 crumbled and the Energy 5 turned the Energy 4, he transferred to the ACC’s Hurricanes to stay on the the highest stage of faculty soccer competitors. Sanders went from FCS program Jackson State to FBS P4 Colorado.
A director of participant personnel for a Group of 5 faculty soccer crew laughed when instructed the variety of whole transfers for 2018 — 18?! Seven gamers from his program transferred up this offseason and 4 transferred in from decrease ranges of faculty soccer. He spoke to ESPN anonymously as a result of he was not approved to talk on the report.
One of many seven transfers he misplaced was an offensive lineman who had scarcely performed — simply 15 snaps all season. He left for a “blue-chip” Energy 4 program that provided him due to his dimension, a pure projection transfer.
The director of participant personnel says his program will lose this battle each time to a Energy 4 program as a result of it would not have the NIL cash to compete. He estimated the vary for a participant transferring as much as a Energy 4 program for a beginning position to be within the mid-six figures.
An FCS offensive coordinator — additionally not approved by his crew to talk — stated he had an “common, at finest” sort out switch out of his program in December for a deal at an FBS faculty value $1.7 million.
“It is a lot tougher to retain gamers, particularly on the decrease ranges,” the G5 participant personnel director stated.
One scouting director for an NFL membership stated he has been having conversations together with his workers members about how they may want to alter their course of and spend much less time going to smaller packages. “Go the place the gamers are,” he stated.
The G5 director of participant personnel stated the director-level scouts have not been coming to scout his program the previous couple of years as a result of his seniors have transferred up. Space scouts are nonetheless coming by way of — for now. One space scout stated he is nonetheless going to all of his “free agent faculties” exterior of the facility conferences, however he has seen that lots of his friends usually are not.
“There’s simply much less expertise out there at these ranges,” the scout stated. “And generally, it is irritating as a result of they will depart, as an example, San Jose State or Louisiana Tech or one thing, they usually find yourself being a backup at a Large 12 faculty, or a Large Ten faculty, and also you assume, ‘Wow, they obtained paid,’ they usually’re not even on the sphere.”
The rise in transfers could make a scout’s job tougher in some methods as a result of it requires extra work to gather data on the participant’s persona and inside make-up throughout a number of faculties, nevertheless it has additionally made their job simpler as a result of they’ll get a extra correct thought of how the prospect will carry out on the NFL stage.
“The toughest factor to do in scouting, for my part, is normalizing competitors,” one NFL analytics staffer stated. “It is why it makes SEC gamers usually simpler to mission — you already know they’re additionally going towards elite gamers.”
“Seeing them at a giant program towards actual NFL expertise could be very useful,” one veteran NFL space scout stated. “I’ve thought a couple of instances this yr, ‘I wager this dude would’ve tricked somebody into drafting him if he would’ve stayed the place he was.'”
1:15
Tannenbaum: Jaxson Dart will go within the first spherical
Mike Tannenbaum joins “SportsCenter” to interrupt down the place he thinks QB Jaxson Dart might go within the NFL draft following a robust efficiency on the scouting mix.
A switch on a participant’s résumé was such an outlier that it will immediate questions. Gamers needed to clarify and defend themselves for transferring. Now that the school soccer panorama has modified a lot, a switch is not an computerized crimson flag. One space scout stated it is solely a deterrent if the participant has transferred three to 4 instances on the Energy 4 stage, but additionally stated scouts discover it refreshing when a participant has by no means transferred.
Raiders basic supervisor John Spytek labored as Tampa Bay’s assistant basic supervisor earlier than accepting the Raiders job in January. The Buccaneers have had success drafting small faculty gamers comparable to former guard Ali Marpet out of D-II Hobart Faculty and guard Alex Cappa out of D-II Humboldt State.
“Perhaps these guys switch up now,” Spytek stated. “Perhaps they do not. I give a number of respect to the fellows that stick it out with the college they’re at and take a smaller NIL deal than they may have gotten if they’d have transferred to the massive one. There is a loyalty and a top quality to that human that actually stands out. And there is a couple guys on this draft this yr that had the identical alternative.”
On the identical time, transferring up has develop into so anticipated and regular on this period of faculty soccer that it is nearly a crimson flag when an elite participant at a decrease stage would not take an opportunity to face higher competitors. One other NFL scout stated when his crew mentioned William & Mary sort out Charles Grant, one of many seven FCS gamers on the mix, it questioned why he did not switch up when he had alternatives. Why did not he wish to check himself?
DELAWARE RUNNING BACK Marcus Yarns — one of many seven FCS mix invitations — might have moved as much as a much bigger program for his final season, however he heard greater packages had been considering him as a part of a one-two punch at operating again, that means his snap depend would lower. So he remained a Blue Hen earlier than he knew what the cash would seem like, partly as a result of he knew he’d be the featured again but additionally as a result of Delaware had been loyal to him throughout the highschool recruiting course of. Yarns stated he fractured his knee at first of his senior season of highschool and misplaced all of his Energy 5 provides.
“Taking part in towards higher competitors was at all times a very good factor, and I felt as if I might,” Yarns stated. “But it surely [was] by no means a risk that I could not get to the NFL. I at all times thought I had the expertise to make it to the place I am at now, so I simply stayed down.”
He completed the season with 5 100-yard speeding video games, 1,141 whole yards, 126.8 yards per recreation and 11 whole touchdowns. The expertise of dropping all his Energy 5 provides throughout his senior highschool season and “seeing how the enterprise operated in that vogue” made him cautious of trusting any provides to switch up.
“[Delaware] actually believes in me, they usually have belief in me, so it is solely proper for me to remain there and stay loyal.”
A former NFL entrance workplace staffer who works within the faculty soccer business stated there’s a lack of complete information on switch portal technique and success.
“What share of gamers are enjoying extra versus much less, or producing extra versus much less, as they’re transferring up in a stage,” he stated. “I have not seen any actual analysis executed on any of those transfer-type analytics. It could add a number of worth if you happen to knew about sure positions that translate higher from stage to stage, or sure main indicators that you can use that will offer you extra confidence in portal success.”
Final offseason, 26 Solar Belt Convention gamers transferred as much as the P4. Based on Arkansas radio reporter Kara Richey, who tracked the strikes, two of the 26 had their snap depend enhance in 2024. 4 gamers noticed their snap counts lower by 10% or much less and the remaining 20 had snap counts lower by greater than 10%.
“You by no means know what is going on to occur whenever you change schemes, play towards totally different competitors, after which have totally different coaches who’re asking you to do various things,” the Group of 5 personnel director stated. “So, you are rolling the cube. … Should you had stayed on the G5 program you had been excelling in, you play 500 snaps, or catch 100 balls. [The scouts are] at the least going to find out about you. They’re going to do much more work on you than they’ll do on the Energy 4 backup.”
“You get higher whenever you play,” one space scout stated. “So usually, guys make that greatest leap throughout their ultimate yr and the sunshine simply begins to come back on. To waste it now … you are at Texas A&M, and also you’re enjoying on the second string on the particular groups.”
0:29
Isaiah Bond clocks 4.39 at NFL Mix
Isaiah Bond exhibits off his pace with a 4.39-second 40-yard sprint on the NFL Mix.
ZABEL TOOK A seat on a sofa within the Excel Sports activities suite on the prospects’ lodge in Indianapolis, and joined his fellow Excel Sports activities-represented offensive linemen to look at the linebackers run the 40. He had simply completed an extended day of interviews with NFL groups, and will lastly decompress together with his crew. Excel Sports activities coaching mate and Washington linebacker Carson Bruener was on deck to run, and all of the company workers and gamers within the suite went silent as he knelt on the beginning line.
“Right here we go!” Zabel yelled. “Right here we go! 4.58, 4.58!
“He is scooting!”
When Bruener crossed the end line in precisely 4.58 seconds, everybody within the room erupted. Zabel whooped and clapped for his pal. It was this identical vitality that obtained him voted captain in his ultimate season at North Dakota State.
“It is one thing I maintain actually near my coronary heart, being a captain my senior yr, as a result of it is one of many greatest honors you will get in this system,” Zabel stated. “It is a type of offers the place you simply do not are available in and be a captain immediately your first or second yr, you bought to place within the sweat fairness and proceed to show you are a frontrunner in how exhausting you labored on the sphere, off the sphere.”
A captaincy would have been out of attain if he had transferred. And that intangible piece of a soccer crew — the player-created tradition — is what Zabel sees dying out as teammates transferred up and the small faculty prospect turned a rarity.
“If you lose guys like that, it feels such as you lose key elements of your crew, key elements of your packages. … However on the identical time, you may by no means have the ability to blame someone for bettering themselves. In order that’s simply the truth of faculty soccer these days.”
